November 2007
In November 2007 The Archive recorded the following events :
1st – 4th NOVEMBER 2007
NOVEMBERTAGUNG 2007 : Conference For Younger Researchers in History and Philosophy of Mathematics
Bonn. Germany.
Details to be added
—oOo—
1st NOVEMBER 2007
4:30 PM Seminar Room : 10 Merton Street Oxford : Philosophy of Physics Seminar
David WALLACE (Oxford) : Postulate or Theorem ? The Born Rule, Everett Style.
Click here for link to recording
Click here for Speakers Overheads and related material
—oOo—
2nd NOVEMBER 2007
Oxford OASIS Seminar
New Lecture Theatre B Oxford Computing Lab (Convenor : Bob COECKE)
Basil HILEY :
Clifford Algebras and Shadow Phase Spaces in Quantum Theory : How to Unite the Formalisms of Schrodinger, Pauli and Dirac with the Interpretational Perspective of Bohm within one algebraic structure
Click here for link to recording
Click here for Speakers Overheads and related material
Click here for link to recording
Click here for Speakers Overheads and related material
—oOo—
3rd-4th NOVEMBER 2007
First Workshop on The Philosophy of Information and Logic
New Lecture Theatre B Oxford Computing |Laboratory
Further details of Program and other information to be added.
—oOo—
4th NOVEMBER 2007
Notes and memoranda of discussions with Prof. Basil HILEY on Algebraic frameworks for the Unification of Physics – connecting the Dirac Pauli and Heisenberg algebras and forming an alternative to the Hilbert Space Formalism
—oOo—
Notes and memoranda of Discussion with F.W. Lawvere on the 1973 Talk given by Alexandre Grothendieck at the Buffalo Mathematics Colloquium and his presentation of an implicit program for “Bypassing Logic”
—oOo—
Discussions of 2 Papers assessed by Physics Forum as the most influential published in 2006
A Lorentzian Version of Non-Commutative Geometry and a New Approach to the Standard Model
by John BARRETT and Alain CONNES
Could QM be an approximation to A Deeper Underlying Theory ?
By Lee SMOLIN
—oOo—
5th NOVEMBER 2007
REHSEIS Workshop Rue Tolbiac Paris
in Seminar Programme “Recherche sur La Generalite”
14:00 – 18:00 : Presentation and General Discussion of 2 Texts :
Emily GROSHOLZ : Leibniz, Analysis, Generalization and The Notion of Canonical Objects
Eberhard KNOBLOCH : Generality in Leibniz’s Mathematics and its relation to his Metaphysics
With participation by Karine CHEMLA, Emily GROSHOLZ, Renaud CHORLAY, David RABOUIN and others
Click here for Recording of Discussions
Click here for Notes of Seminar
—oOo—
9th NOVEMBER 2007
Memorandum/Record of Discussions on the relative position of Geometric verus Arithmetical Concepts with respect to the ontological, the epistemic and cognitive, and the logico-semantic dimensions of the notion of “being a foundation for” with respect to mathematical concepts.
See link to Transcript
—oOo—
10th NOVEMBER 2007
Seminaire MaMuPhi ENS
Évaluation de la music theory de David Lewin (Stephan Schaub et François Nicolas)
- · Stephan Schaub – Statut de la formalisation mathématique dans la « music theory » américaine : une lecture de l’échange entre Edward T. Cone et David Lewin (Perspectives of New Music 1967 et 1969).
- · François Nicolas – « Comme Freud, Schoenberg est mort en Amérique » :
« Déconstruire la music theory (1) : David Lewin »
« Déconstruire la music theory (2) : Milton Babbitt »
—oOo—
NOVEMBER 14-17, 2007, Faculty of Philosophy Complutense University, Madrid, Spain
EPSA 2007
The First of the Biennial Conferences of The EUROPEAN PHILOSOPHY OF SCIENCE ASSOCIATION was held at The Faculty of Philosophy of the Complutense University of Madrid from
NOVEMBER 14th – 17th 2007
—oOo—
For The Complete Program of the Conference see : http://www.ucm.es/info/epsa07/misc/EPSA07_Programme.pdf
For Abstracts of the Talks see http://www.ucm.es/info/epsa07/misc/EPSA07_BookOfAbstracts.pdf
For Information on the venue and other Information relating to the Conference see http://www.ucm.es/info/epsa07/index.html and http://www.ucm.es/info/epsa07/epsa07_venue/index.html
Within the Conference Program, the Archive Trust recorded the Talks indicated below :
DAY ONE : WEDNESDAY 14th NOVEMBER 2007
15:00: Registration Faculty of Philosophy, UCM
16:00 – 17:00
Opening of the Conference
Room: Paraninfo
Carmen Acebal Sarabia (ViceRector of Research, Complutense University)
Juan Manuel Navarro Cordón (Dean, Faculty of Philosophy, Complutense University)
Mauricio Suárez (Chair, Organising Committee, EPSA07)
Matti Sintonen (President, EPSA)
17: 00 – 17:30 Coffee Break
17:30 – 19:30 Parallel Sessions I
I: General Philosophy of Science
(Causation)
Room: Paraninfo
Chair: Carl Hoefer (Autonomous University of Barcelona)
17.30 –18.00 Max Kistler (Université Pierre Mendès-France, Grenoble and Institut Jean Nicod, Paris) “Mechanistic Explanation and Causation” (1)
18.00 – 18.30 Alex Broadbent (University of Cambridge) “The Difference between Cause and Condition” (2)
18.30 – 19.00 Robert Kowalenko (University of Hertfordshire) “A Curve-Fitting Approach to Ceteris Paribus Laws” (3)
19.00 – 19.30 Mathias Frisch (University of Maryland) “Causation and Physics” (4)
II: Formal Methods in the Philosophy of Science
(Philosophy of Mathematics)
Room: A217
Chair: Miklós Rédei (London School of Economics)
17.30 – 18.00 Mark van Atten (IHPST(CNRS/Paris I/ENS)) “Phenomenology and Transcendental Arguments in Mathematics: Brouwer’s 1927 Constructive proof of the ‘Bar Theorem’” (5)
Click here for Recording of this Talk
Click here for Speakers Overheads or Notes of talk and related material
—oOo—
18.00 – 18.30 José Ferreirós (University of Seville) “Mathematical Knowledge and the Interplay of Practices” (6)
Click here for Recording of this Talk
Click here for Speakers Overheads or Notes of talk and related material
—oOo—
18.30 – 19.00 Mario Santos-Sousa (Autonomous University of Madrid) “Natural Mathematics: A Pluralistic Approach to Mathematical Cognition” (7)
Click here for Recording of this Talk
Click here for Speakers Overheads or Notes of talk and related material
—oOo—
III: Philosophy of Natural Sciences
(Geometry and Matter)
Room: Salón de Grados
Chair: Oliver Pooley (Oxford University)
17.30 – 18.00 Norman Sieroka (ETH Zurich) “Dynamic Agents and Geometrisation: A Weylian Approach towards Theories of Matter” (8)
Click here for Recording of this Talk
Click here for Speakers Overheads or Notes of talk and related material
—oOo—
18.00 – 18.30 Dennis Lehmkuhl (University of Oxford) “Geometrization(s) of Matter” (9)
Click here for Recording of this Talk
Click here for Speakers Overheads or Notes of talk and related material
—oOo—
18.30 – 19.00 Eric Audureau (CEPERC/CNRS/University of Provence) and Gabriella Crocco (CEPERC/CNRS/University of Provence) “Relativity Theory and Poincare’s Conception of Space” (10)
Click here for Recording of this Talk
Click here for Speakers Overheads or Notes of talk and related material
—oOo—
19.00 – 19.30 Adán Sus (Autonomous University of Barcelona) “Absolute Objects and General Relativity: Dynamical Considerations” (11)
Click here for Recording of this Talk
Click here for Speakers Overheads or Notes of talk and related material
—oOo—
V: Historical, Social and Cultural Studies of Philosophy of Science
(Gender and Values in Science)
Room: Sala de Juntas
Chair: Berna Kilinc (Bogazici University)
17.30 – 18.00 Maria Rentetzi (National Technical University of Athens) “Rose Rand: Between two Different Gendered Cultures of Physics and Philosophy in Interwar Vienna” (12)
18.00 – 18.30 Hans Puehretmayer (University of Vienna) “Beyond Judgemental Relativism: Combining Feminist Standpoint Theories and Critical Realism” (13)
18.30 – 19.00 Kristina Rolin (Helsinki School of Economics) “Science as Collective Knowledge” (14)
—oOo—
DAY TWO THURSDAY 15th NOVEMBER 2011
9:00 – 11:30 Parallel Sessions II
I: General Philosophy of Science
(Realism)
Room: Paraninfo
Chair: Stathis Psillos (University of Athens)
9.00 – 9.30 Panu Raatikainen (University of Helsinki) “Theories of Reference and the Philosophy of Science” (15)
Click here for Recording of this Talk
Click here for Speakers Overheads or Notes of talk and related material
—oOo—
9.30 – 10.00 Fabrice Pataut (IHPST) “Verifiability, Scientific Realism and Constructive Empiricism” (16)
Click here for Recording of this Talk
Click here for Speakers Overheads or Notes of talk and related material
—oOo—
10.00 – 10.30 Wang-Yen Lee (University of Cambridge) “The Probative Force and Dialectical Value of Structure-Oriented Second-Order Abductive Arguments for Scientific Realism” (17)
Click here for Recording of this Talk
Click here for Speakers Overheads or Notes of talk and related material
—oOo—
10.30 – 11.00 Axel Gelfert (National University of Singapore) “Coherence and Indirect Confirmation between Scientific Models: A Case Study and its Epistemological Implications” (18)
Click here for Recording of this Talk
Click here for Speakers Overheads or Notes of talk and related material
—oOo—
11.00 – 11.30 Andreas Karitzis (University of Athens) “Defending Realism: Can Ontology Do the Trick?” (19)
Click here for Recording of this Talk
Click here for Speakers Overheads or Notes of talk and related material
—oOo—
II: Formal Methods in Philosophy of Science
(Mathematics and Logic)
Room: A217
Chair: Wolfgang Spohn (University of Konstanz)
9.30 – 10.00 Demetra Christopoulou “How to Deal with Ithe Janus’ Face of Natural Numbers” (20)
Click here for Recording of this Talk
Click here for Speakers Overheads or Notes of talk and related material
—oOo—
10.00 – 10.30 Georg Schiemer (University Vienna) “Frege and Peano on Quantification and Logical Scope” (21)
Click here for Recording of this Talk
Click here for Speakers Overheads or Notes of talk and related material
—oOo—
10.30 – 11.00 Jean-Pierre Marquis (University of Montréal) “Mathematical Forms and Forms of Mathematics: Homotopy Types” (22)
Click here for Recording of this Talk
Click here for Speakers Overheads or Notes of talk and related material
—oOo—
11.00 – 11.30 Charlotte Werndl (University of Cambridge) “Mathematical Definitions that Capture Real-World Phenomena or Features: On the Formation and Justification of Definitions” (23)
Click here for Recording of this Talk
Click here for Speakers Overheads or Notes of talk and related material
—oOo—
III: Philosophy of Natural Sciences
(Principles in Physics)
Room: Salón de Grados
Chair: Mauro Dorato (University of Rome III)
9.00 – 9.30 Maarten Van Dyck (Ghent University) “The Historical A Priori: The Case of Inertia” (24)
Click here for Recording of this Talk
Click here for Speakers Overheads or Notes of talk and related material
—oOo—
9.30 – 10.00 Michael Stöltzner (University of Wuppertal) “Can the Principle of Least Action be Considered a Relativised a Priori?” (25)
Click here for Recording of this Talk
Click here for Speakers Overheads or Notes of talk and related material
—oOo—
10.00 – 10.30 Chrysovalantis Stergiou (National Technical University of Athens) “Some Remarks on Causal Processes in Classical and Local Quantum Physics” (26)
Click here for Recording of this Talk
Click here for Speakers Overheads or Notes of talk and related material
—oOo—
10.30 – 11.00 Laura Felline (University of Rome III) “Structural Explanation: From Relativity to Quantum Mechanics” (27)
Click here for Recording of this Talk
Click here for Speakers Overheads or Notes of talk and related material
—oOo—
11.00 – 11.30 Richard Healey (University of Arizona) “Gauge Symmetry and the Theta-Vacuum” (28)
Click here for Recording of this Talk
Click here for Speakers Overheads or Notes of talk and related material
—oOo—
IV: Philosophy of Social Sciences
(Psychology & Rationality)
Room: Sala de Juntas
Chair: Claude Debru (ENS)
9.00 – 9.30 Caterina Marchionni (Erasmus University Rotterdam) and Jack Vromen (Erasmus University Rotterdam) “Ultimate and Proximate Explanations of Cooperative Behaviour: Plurality or Integration?” (29)
9.30 – 10.00 Athanasios Raftopoulos (University of Cyprus) “Ambiguous Figures and Representationalism” (30)
10.00 – 10.30 Corrado Sinigaglia (University of Milan) “The Shared Space of Actions: Mirror Neurons and Motor Intentionality” (31)
10.30 – 11.00 Antonio Zilhao (University of Lisbon) “Incontinence, Honouring Sunk Costs and Rationality” (32)
11.00 – 11.30 Simone Gozzano (University of L’Aquila) “Multiple Realizability and Identity’’ (33)
11:30 – 12:00 Coffee Break
12:00 – 13:15
Plenary Lecture
Room: Paraninfo
Chair: Maria Carla Galavotti (University of Bologna)
Anne Fagot-Largeault (Collège de France): “Styles in Philosophy of Science”
Click here for Recording of this Plenary Lecture
Click here for Speakers Overheads or Notes of talk and related material
—oOo—
13:15 – 15:00 Lunch Break
15:00 – 17:00 Parallel Sessions III
I: General Philosophy of Science
(Models and Representation)
Room: Paraninfo
Chair: Xavier de Donato (UNAM, Mexico)
15.00 – 15.30 Tarja Knuuttila (University of Helsinki) “Some Consequences of Pragmatism: Whatever Happened to the Notion of Representation in the Philosophy of Science” (34)
Click here for Recording of this Talk
Click here for Speakers Overheads or Notes of talk and related material
—oOo—
15.30 – 16.00 Demetris Portides (University of Cyprus) “Idealization and Abstraction in Scientific Modelling” (35)
Click here for Recording of this Talk
Click here for Speakers Overheads or Notes of talk and related material
—oOo—
16.00 – 16.30 Uskali Maki (University of Helsinki) “Models and the Locus of their Truth” (36)
Click here for Recording of this Talk
Click here for Speakers Overheads or Notes of talk and related material
—oOo—
16.30 – 17.00 Marion Vorms (IHPST) “Understanding Theories: Formats Matter” (37)
Click here for Recording of this Talk
Click here for Speakers Overheads or Notes of talk and related material
—oOo—
II: Formal Methods in Philosophy of Science
(Causation and Probability)
Room: A217
Chair: Mathias Frisch (University of Maryland)
15.00 – 15.30 Bert Leuridan (Ghent University) “The Need for Causal Modellling in Philosophy of Science” (38)
15.30 – 16.00 Alessio Moneta (Max Planck Institute of Economics) “Can Graphical Causal Inference Be Extended to Nonlinear Models? An Assessment of Nonparametric Independence Tests” (39)
16.00 – 16.30 Sun Demirli (Bogazici University) “Does Lewis’ Account of Chance Bear on Scientific Ontology?” (40)
16.30 – 17.00 Jan Sprenger (University of Bonn) “Statistics do not Require Frequentist Justifications” (41)
III: Philosophy of Natural Sciences
(Space and Time)
Room: Salón de Grados
Chair: Carl Hoefer (Autonomous University of Barcelona)
15.00 – 15.30 Oliver Pooley (Oxford University) “Background Independence” (42)
Click here for Recording of this Talk
Click here for Speakers Overheads or Notes of talk and related material
—oOo—
15.30 – 16.00 Hanoch Ben-Yami (Central European University) “Backward Light-cone Simultaneity, with Special Application to the Twin Paradox” (43)
Click here for Recording of this Talk
Click here for Speakers Overheads or Notes of talk and related material
—oOo—
16.00 – 16.30 Laszlo E. Szabó (Eötvös University) “Empirical Foundation of Space and Time” (44)
Click here for Recording of this Talk
Click here for Speakers Overheads or Notes of talk and related material
—oOo—
16.30 – 17.00 Steven Savitt (University of British Columbia) “The Transient Nows” (45)
Click here for Recording of this Talk
Click here for Speakers Overheads or Notes of talk and related material
—oOo—
V: Historical, Social and Cultural Studies of Philosophy of Science
(Case Studies)
Room: Sala de Juntas
Chair: Mieke Boon (University of Twente)
15.00 – 15.30 Nathalie Gontier (Free University of Brussels, VUB) “Philosophy of Anthropology and the Gradualism versus Punctuated Equilibrium Debate” (46)
15.30 – 16.00 Sabine Plaud (University of Paris I) “On Photographs and Phonographs: The Influence of Some Technical Innovations on Ernst Mach’s and Ludwig Wittgenstein’s Conceptions of Pictures” (47)
16.00 – 16.30 Floriane Blanc (LEPS) “Analyzing an Aspect of the Inaugural Lectures of the Paris Museum of Natural History: An Appropriate Concept of Representation” (48)
16.30 – 17.00 Geerdt Magiels (Free University of Brussels) and Gustaaf Cornelis (Free University of Brussels) “Dr Jan Ingen Housz, The Forgotten Discoverer of Photosynthesis” (49)
17:00-17:30 Coffee Break
17:30 – 19:30 Parallel Sessions IV
I: General Philosophy of Science
(Structuralism)
Room: Paraninfo
Chair: Dennis Dieks (Utrecht University)
17.30 – 18.00 F.A. Muller (Erasmus University Rotterdam/Utrecht University) “The Concept of Structure” (50)
Click here for Recording of this Talk
Click here for Speakers Overheads or Notes of talk and related material
—oOo—
18.00 – 18.30 Holger Lyre (University of Bonn) “Structural Realism: Intermediate View and Laws of Nature” (51)
Click here for Recording of this Talk
Click here for Speakers Overheads or Notes of talk and related material
—oOo—
18.30 – 19.00 Angelo Cei (University of Leeds) “A Form of Ramseyan Humility? David Lewis’s version of the Ramsey Sentence and the debate on Structural Realism”(52)
Click here for Recording of this Talk
Click here for Speakers Overheads or Notes of talk and related material
—oOo—
19.00 – 19.30 Juha Saatsi (University of Leeds) “Whence Ontological Structural Realism?” (53)
Click here for Recording of this Talk
Click here for Speakers Overheads or Notes of talk and related material
—oOo—
IIIa: Philosophy of Natural Sciences
(Reductionism)
Room: A217
Chair: Henk De Regt (University of Amsterdam)
17.30 – 18.00 Peter Fazekas (Budapest University of Technology and Economics) “Different Models of Reduction and the Inevitability of Bridge-Laws” (54)
18.00 – 18.30 Markus Eronen (University of Osnabrück) “Reductionism and Problems of Explanatory Pluralism” (55)
18.30 – 19.00 Jens Harbecke (University of Lausanne/University of Bern) “Conservative and Eliminative Reduction: Exploring the Spectrum” (56)
19.00 – 19.30 Simon Bowes (University of Sussex) “Natural Kinds and Reduction in the Cognitive Sciences” (57)
IIIb: Philosophy of Natural Sciences
(Quantum Theory)
Room: Salón de Grados
Chair: Pedro Sánchez and Albert Solé (Complutense University)
17.30 – 18.00 Robin Hendry (Durham University) “The Chemical Bond: Structure, Energy and Explanation” (58)
Click here for Recording of this Talk
Click here for Speakers Overheads or Notes of talk and related material
—oOo—
18.00 – 18.30 Peter Vickers (University of Leeds) “Bohr’s Theory of the Atom: Content, Closure and Consistency” (59)
Click here for Recording of this Talk
Click here for Speakers Overheads or Notes of talk and related material
—oOo—
18.30 – 19.00 Hernán Pringe (University of Pittsburgh) “Cassirer and Bohr on Intuitive and Symbolic Knowledge in Quantum Theory” (60)
Click here for Recording of this Talk
Click here for Speakers Overheads or Notes of talk and related material
—oOo—
19.00 – 19.30 Brigitte Falkenburg (University of Dortmund) “Wave-particle Duality in Physical Practice” (61)
Click here for Recording of this Talk
Click here for Speakers Overheads or Notes of talk and related material
—oOo—
V: Historical, Cultural and Social Studies of Science
(Carnap/Commerce)
Room: Sala de Juntas
Chair: Friedrich Stadler (Vienna Circle Institute)
17.30 – 18.00 Thomas Uebel (University of Manchester) “Carnap, Explication and
Ramseyfication” (62)
Click here for Recording of this Talk
Click here for Speakers Overheads or Notes of talk and related material
—oOo—
18.00 – 18.30 Paul Franco (University of Pennsylvania) “The Constitutive A Priori and the Quine/Carnap Debate” (63)
Click here for Recording of this Talk
Click here for Speakers Overheads or Notes of talk and related material
—oOo—
18.30 – 19.00 Lieven Decock (Free University of Amsterdam) “Carnap and Quine on the Analytic-Synthetic Distinctions” (64)
Click here for Recording of this Talk
Click here for Speakers Overheads or Notes of talk and related material
—oOo—
19.00 – 19.30 Gurol Irzik (Bogazici University) “Is Science Being Commercialised? A Manifesto for Philosophers of Science” (65)
—oOo—
DAY THREE FRIDAY 16th NOVEMBER 2011
09:00 – 11:30 Parallel Sessions V
I: General Philosophy of Science
(Nature of Science)
Room: Paraninfo
Chair: Matti Sintonen (University of Helsinki)
9.00 – 9.30 Jan Faye (University of Copenhagen) “Interpretation in the Natural Sciences” (66)
9.30 – 10.00 Daniel Sirtes (University of Basel) and Marcel Weber (University of Basel) “Scientific Significance Scrutinized” (67)
10.00 – 10.30 Jeremy Kessler (University of Cambridge) “Analogy by Exemplar: A Kuhnian Alternative to Hesse’s Account of Analogy in Science” (68)
10.30 – 11.00 Thomas Reydon (Leibniz University of Hannover) “Natural Kinds as Tools for Philosophers of Science” (69)
11.00 – 11.30 Justin Biddle (Bielefeld University) “The Ambiguously Social Character of Longino’s Theory of Science” (70)
II: Formal Methods in Philosophy of Science
(Statistics and Confirmation)
Room: A217
Chair: Stephan Hartmann (Tilburg University)
9.00 – 9.30 Wolfgang Spohn (University of Konstanz) “Measuring Ranks by the Complete Laws of Iterated Contraction” (71)
9.30 – 10.00 Francesco Calandra (University of Trieste) and Gustavo Cevolani (University of Bologna) “Belief Revision and Truth-Approximation” (72)
10.00 – 10.30 Theo Kuipers (University of Groningen) “Bridging the Gap Between Belief Revision and Truth Approximation” (73)
10.30 – 11.00 Carl Wagner (University of Tennessee) “Old Evidence and New Explanation” (74)
11.00 – 11.30 Roberto Festa (University of Trieste), Vincenzo Crupi (University of Trieste) and Carlo Buttasi (University of Trieste) “The Grammar of Confirmation” (75)
IIIa: Philosophy of Natural Sciences
(Biomedicine, Ecology)
Room: A25
Chair: Sophia Efstathiou (UCSD / London School of Economics)
9.00 – 9.30 Giovanni Boniolo (IFOM) and Marcello D’Agostino (University of Ferrara) “Biomedical Networks and their Logics” (76)
9.30 – 10.00 Ulrich Krohs (University of Hambrug) “Epistemic Consequences of two Different Strategies for Decomposing Biological Networks” (77)
10.00 – 10.30 Astrid Schwarz (Technical University Darmstadt) “Commuting Concepts and Objects in Scientific Ecology” (78)
10.30 – 11.00 Werner Callebaut (Konrad Lorenz Institute for Evolution and Cognition Research) “Contigency and Inherency in (Eco)EvoDevo” (79)
11.00 – 11.30 Julian Reiss (Erasmus University Rotterdam) “Is There a Role for Clinical Expertise in Evidence-Based Medicine?” (80)
IIIb: Philosophy of Natural Sciences
(Philosophy of Physics)
Room: Salón de Grados
Chair: Isabel Guerra (Complutense University)
9.00 – 9.30 Henrik Zinkernagel (University of Granada) “Causal Fundamentalism in Physics” (81)
9.30 – 10.00 Elena Castellani (University of Florence) “Dualities and Intertheoretic Relations” (82)
10.00 – 10.30 Matteo Morganti (London School of Economics/IHPST) “Individual Particles, Properties and Quantum Statistics” (83)
10.30 – 11.00 Daniel Parker (Virginia Tech) “Was There an Ice Cube There, or Am I Just Remembering It?: Reposing the Question of the Veracity of Memory” (84)
11.00 – 11.30 Dennis Dieks (Utrecht University) “Structuralism, Symmetry and Identical Particles” (85)
Click here for Recording of this Talk
Click here for Speakers Overheads or Notes of talk and related material
—oOo—
IV: Philosophy of Social Sciences
(Philosophy of Economics)
Room: Sala de Juntas
Chair: Uskali Maki (University of Helsinki)
9.00 – 9.30 Ghislaine Idabouk (University of Paris VII) “Randomness, Financial Markets and the Brownian Motion: A Reflection on the Role of Mathematics, its Interactions with Economics and the Ideological Implications in the Financial Theory of the late 20th Century” (86)
9.30 – 10.00 Aki Lehtinen (University of Helsinki) “Farewell to Arrow’s Theorem” (87)
10.00 – 10.30. Stuart Yasgur (London School of Economics) “The Money Pump and the Justification of the Transitivity Condition” (88)
10.30 – 11.00 Menno Rol (University of Groningen) “Explanatory Progress and Tendencies in Economics” (89)
11.00 – 11.30 Hans Radder (Free University of Amsterdam) “Mertonian Values, Scientific Norms and the Commercialisation of Academic Research” (90)
11:30 – 12:00 Coffee Break
12:00 – 13:15
Plenary Lecture
Room: Paraninfo
Chair: Stathis Psillos (University of Athens)
Ilkka Niiniluoto (University of Helsinki): “Theory-Change, Truthlikeness and Belief-Revision”
Click here for Recording of this Plenary Lecture
Click here for Speakers Overheads or Notes of talk and related material
—oOo—
13:15 – 15:00 Lunch Break
15:00 – 17:00 Parallel Sessions VI
Ia: General Philosophy of Science
(Simulation)
Room: Paraninfo
Chair: Martin Carrier (University of Bielefeld)
15.00 – 15.30 Erika Mattila (London School of Economics) “Explanatory and Predictive Functions of Simulations” (91)
15.30 – 16.00 John Michael (University of Vienna) “Simulation as an Epistemic Tool between Theory and Practice” (92)
16.00 – 16.30 Johannes Lenhard (Bielefeld University) “The Platform Concept of Simulation Modelling” (93)
16.30 – 17.00 Claude Debru (ENS) “Neurophilosophy of Sleep and Dreaming” (94)
Ib: General Philosophy of Science
(Experiment and Observation)
Room: Sala de Juntas
Chair: John Worrall (London School of Economics)
15.00 – 15.30 Valeriano Iranzo (University of Valencia) “Severe Tests and Use-Novelty” (95)
15.30 – 16.00 Theodore Arabatzis (University of Athens) “Rethinking the Theory-Ladeness of Observation: Implications for the New Experimentalism” (96)
16.00 – 16.30 Tuomo Tiisala (University of Chicago) “Hacking’s Verificationism” (97)
16.30 – 17.00 Ioannis Votsis (University of Düsseldorf) “Making Contact with Observations” (98)
IIIa: Philosophy of Natural Sciences
(Biology & Values)
Room: A217
Chair: Samir Okasha (University of Bristol)
15.00 – 15.30 Fabrice Gzil (IHPST/Collége de France) “Animal Models of Alzheimer’s Disease and Cognitive Ageing” (99)
15.30 – 16.00 Sophia Efstathiou (UCSD, visiting LSE) “Articulating ‘Race’ in Genetic Terms” (100)
16.00 – 16.30 Emmanuel d’Hombres (University of Paris VII) “Differentiation as a Modality of Evolution: From Biology to Sociology and Back” (101)
16.30 – 17.00 Torsten Wilholt (Bielefeld University), “Values in Science and the Problem of Bias” (102)
IIIb: Philosophy of Natural Sciences
(Quantum Probability)
Room: Salón de Grados
Chair: Iñaki San Pedro (Complutense University)
15.00 – 15.30 Patrick Suppes (Stanford University) “Upper Probabilities, Entanglement and Decoherence” (103)
15.30 – 16.00 Giovanni Valente (University of Maryland) “Is There a Stability Problem for Bayesian Noncommutative Probabilities?” (104)
16.00 – 16.30 Gerd Grasshoff (University of Bern), Samuel Protmann (University of Bern) and Adrian Wüthrich (University of Bern), “Minimal Assumption Derivation of a Bell-type Inequality” (105)
16.30 – 17.00 Tomasz Placek and Leszek Wronski (Jagiellonian University) “On the Infinite EPR-like Correlations” (106)
17:00 – 17:30 Coffee Break
17:30 – 19:30
General Assembly of EPSA
Room: Paraninfo
—oOo—
DAY FOUR SATURDAY 17th NOVEMBER 2011
9:00 – 11:30 Parallel Sessions VII
I: General Philosophy of Science
(Prediction, Chance, and Error)
Room: Paraninfo
Chair: Theo Kuipers (University of Groningen)
9.00 – 9.30 Gerhard Schurz (University of Düsseldorf) “Universal vs. Local Prediction Strategies: A Game Theoretical Approach to the Problem of Induction” (107)
9.30 – 10.00 Sorin Bangu (University of Western Ontario) “The Principle of Indifference and Statistical Tests: A Critique of Gillies’ Eliminative Strategy” (108)
10.00 – 10.30 Cornelis Menke (Bielefeld University) “On the Explanation of Predictive Success due to Chance” (109)
10.30 – 11.00 Marcello D’Agostino (University of Ferrara) and Corrado Sinigaglia (University of Milan) “Forecasting Accuracy and Subjective Probability” (110)
11.00 – 11.30 Jacques Dubucs (IHPST – CNRS) “Intended Models” (111)
IIIa: Philosophy of Natural Sciences
(Biology)
Room: A25
Chair: Giovanni Boniolo (IFOM)
9.00 – 9.30 Andrés L. Jaume (University of Salamanca) “Are all Biological Functions Adaptations?” (112)
9.30 – 10.00 Marshall Abrams (University of Alabama at Birmingham) “Radical Pluralisms about Units of Selection” (113)
10.00 – 10.30 Predrag Sustar (University of Rijeka) “Functions in the Morphospace” (114)
10.30 – 11.00 Johannes Persson (Lund University) “Mechanism-as-activity and the Threat of Polygenic Effects” (115)
11.00 – 11.30 Samir Okasha (Bristol University), “On the Significance of R. A. Fisher’s Fundamental Theorem of Natural Selection” (116)
IIIb: Philosophy of Natural Sciences
(Quantum Mechanics)
Room: Salón de Grados
Chair: Henrik Zinkernagel (University of Granada)
9.00 – 9.30 Alexei Grinbaum (CEA-Saclay) “Reconstruction of Quantum Theory vis-a-vis Interpretation” (117)
Click here for Recording of this Talk
Click here for Speakers Overheads or Notes of talk and related material
—oOo—
9.30 – 10.00 Aristidis Arageorgis (National Technical University of Athens) “Holism and Nonseparability by Analogy” (118)
Click here for Recording of this Talk
Click here for Speakers Overheads or Notes of talk and related material
—oOo—
10.00 – 10.30 George Darby (University of Leeds) “Is Quantum Vagueness Vagueness?” (119)
Click here for Recording of this Talk
Click here for Speakers Overheads or Notes of talk and related material
—oOo—
10.30-11.00 Joss Uffink (Utrecht University)
Motivating Outcome Independence
Click here for Recording of this Talk
Click here for Speakers Overheads or Notes of talk and related material
—oOo—
11.00 – 11.30 Michael Seevinck (Utrecht University) “On the Merits of Modeling Quantum Mechanics Using Semi-Classical Models” (120)
Click here for Recording of this Talk
Click here for Speakers Overheads or Notes of talk and related material
—oOo—
11.30– 12:00 Maria Luisa Dalla Chiara (University of Florence), Roberto Giuntini (University of Cagliari), Roberto Leporini (University of Bergamo) and Giuliano Toraldo di Francia (University of Florence),
“Holistic Semantics: From Quantum Theory to Music : A Quantum Information-based understanding of Quantum Logical Structures(s)” (121)
Click here for Recording of this Talk
Click here for Speakers Overheads or Notes of talk and related material
—oOo—
IV: Philosophy of Social Sciences
(Realism, Relativism, Normativity)
Room: Sala de Juntas
Chair: Alfred Nordmann (Darmstaadt University)
9.00 – 9.30 Daniel Andler (University of Paris IV, Sorbonne/ENS) “Naturalism and the Scientific Status of the Social Sciences” (122)
9.30 – 10.00 Hans Bernhard Schmid (University of Basel) “Intentional Autonomy and Methodological Individualism” (123)
10.00 – 10.30 Caroline Baumann (Cambridge University) “Reconsidering Gilbert’s Account of Norm-Guided Behaviour” (124)
10.30 – 11.00 Erik Weber (Ghent University)”Social Mechanisms, Causal Inference and the Policy Relevance of Social Science” (125)
11.00 – 11.30 Martin Kusch (University of Cambridge) “Boghossian on Relativism and Constructivism – A Critique” (126)
V: Historical, Social and Cultural Studies of Philosophy of Science
(Vienna Circle / Feyerabend)
Room: A217
Chair: Thomas Uebel (University of Manchester)
9.00 – 9.30 Sirkku Ikonen (University of Helsinki) “The Vienna Circle, Lebensphilosophie and the Analytic-Continental Divide in Philosophy” (127)
9.30 – 10.00 Edwin Glassner (Institute Vienna Circle) “Between Pure Intuition and Popular Impercipience: Schlick and the Early Reception of Relativity Theory” (128)
10.00 – 10.30 Flavia Padovani (University of Geneva) “Topologies of Time in the 1920’s: Reichenbach, Carnap, Lewin” (129)
10.30 – 11.00 Matteo Collodel (University of Venice “Ca’ Foscari”) “The Last ‘Viennese’: Feyerabend, Logical Empiricism and the Vienna Circle” (130)
11.00 – 11.30 Paul Hoyningen-Huene (University of Hannover) and Eric Oberheim (Humboldt University of Berlin) “Reassessing Feyerabend’s Philosophy” (131)
11:30 – 12:00 Coffee Break
12:00 – 13.15
Plenary Lecture
Room: Paraninfo
Chair: Mauricio Suárez (Complutense University)
Michael Friedman (Stanford University): “Einstein, Kant and the A Priori”
Click here for Recording of this Plenary Lecture
Click here for Speakers Overheads or Notes of talk and related material
—oOo—
13:15 – 15:00 Lunch Break
15:00 – 17:00 Parallel Sessions VIII
I: General Philosophy of Science
(Theory and Phenomena)
Room: Paraninfo
Chair: Robin Hendry (University of Durham)
15.00 – 15.30 Martin Carrier (Bielefeld University) “Theories for Use: On the Bearing of Basic Science on Practical Problems” (132)
15.30 – 16.00 Christian Sachse (University of Lausanne) “Relation of Theories and Concepts” (133)
16.00 – 16.30 Mieke Boon (University of Twente) “Phenomena: A Transcendental Stance” (134)
16.30 – 17.00 Jan-Willem Romeijn (University of Groningen) “Formal Models of Explorative Experiments” (135)
II: Formal Methods in Philosophy of Science
(Formal Epistemology and Semantics)
Room: A217
Chair: Sorin Bangu (University of Toronto)
15.00 – 15.30 Henri Galinon (IHPST – CNRS) “Deflationism, Inferential Semantics and the Logicality of ‘True’” (136)
15.30 – 16.00 Yves Bouchard (University of Sherbrooke) “Epistemic Closure in Context” (137)
16.00 – 16.30 Gabriella Pigozzi (University of Luxembourg) “Evaluating Social Decision Rules” (138)
16.30 – 17.00 Neil Kennedy (University of Quebec at Montreal / University of Paris I) and Carlo Proietti (University of Paris I / IHPST) “Yet Another Paper on Fitch’s Paradox” (139)
III: Philosophy of Natural Sciences
(Models and Data)
Room: Salón de Grados
Chair: Tarja Knuuttila (University of Helsinki)
15.00 – 15.30 John Worrall (London School of Economics) “Do we Need some Large, Simple Randomized Trials?” (140)
15.30 – 16.00. Lawrence Shapiro (University of Wisconsin, Madison) and Thomas Polger (University of Cincinnati) “The Dimensions of Realisation” (141)
16.00 – 16.30 Sabina Leonelli (London School of Economics) “Can We Have Knowledge Integration without Theoretical Unification? The Travel of Data in Model Organism Biology” (142)
16.30 – 17.00 Xavier de Donato (UNAM, Mexico) “Interactive Representations in Science: From Modelization to Interaction” (143)
IV: Philosophy of Social Sciences
(Semantics and Games)
Room: Sala de Juntas
Chair: Martin Kusch (University of Cambridge)
15.00 – 15.30 Jesús Zamora (Spanish National Open University, UNED) “What Game Do Scientists Play?” (144)
15.30 – 16.00 Aspassia Kanellou “On the Distinction between Content Realism and Realism about Intentional States” (145)
16.00 – 16.30 Alexandra Arapinis (IHPST) “How to Maintain Literalism Without Change of Semantic Paradigm” (146)
16.30 – 17.00 Claudia Bianchi (University San Raffaele, Milan) and Nicla Vassallo (University of Genova) “Semantic Contextualism: An Epistemic Account” (147)
17:00
Closing of the Conference
—oOo—
November 16th 2007
Oxford OASIS Seminar New Lecture Theatre B Oxford Computing Lab, Oxford. (Convenor : Bob COECKE)
Tim PALMER FRS (ECMWF Reading)
Bell Inequalities, Free variables and the Undecidability of Chaotic Invariant Sets
Click here for link to recording
Click here for Speakers Overheads and related material
—oOo—
19th NOVEMBER 2007
REHSEIS Paris University Denis Diderot Paris 7 :
1 day Symposium on History and Philosophy of Mathematics
Series : Pratiques et Problemes II
Speakers : S. LAMASSE ; R. FILDHAY ; N. VERDIER ; J. GRAY
Recordings of (Part of) Talk by Jeremy GRAY (Open University UK) : Hilbert’s List of Problems and their influence on 20th Century Mathematics
Click here for link to recording
Click here for Speakers Overheads and related material
—oOo—
Norbert VERDIER : Nineteenth Century Mathematicl Journals : Their Readership and Influence
Click here for link to recording
Click here for Speakers Overheads and related material
—oOo—
21st NOVEMBER 2007
Paris Observtoire : Seminar in Series on History of Astronomy
J-C. PECKER : A Short History of Cosmological Heresies from Aristotle to Hoyle
(Alternative Title : Zwicky, Eddington and Narlikar verus Gamow and Pius XII : Durable Cosmological Heresies)
Click here for link to recording
Click here for Speakers Overheads and related material
—oOo—
21st NOVEMBER 2011 – 25th NOVEMBER 2011
NOTES MEMORANDA and TRANSCRIPTS OF DISCUSSIONS WITH F.W. LAWVERE DURING HIS VISIT TO PARIS
For THE HOUZEL SYMPOSIUM and Other Events (See Below)
Links to Notes Memoranda and Transcripts to be Added.
—oOo—
22nd NOVEMBER 2007
Seminar on Categories en Physique ENS PARIS
F.W. LAWVERE :
Euler, Maxwell and Grothendieck : 3 Phases in The Searchfor The Effective Mathematical Representation of The Cohesion Underlying Space
Click here for link to recording
Click here for Speakers Overheads Notes of Seminar and related material
—oOo—
23rd NOVEMBER 2007
Institut Henri Poincare Paris
A One Day SYMPOSIUM IN HONOUR OF Christian HOUZEL
Click here for Programme and Poster of The Symposium
Opening Address (In Absence of Professor Pierre CARTIER, who was forced by bereavement to delegate his rome as the Chair of this Meeting) : Introduction to the Symposium.
10:15-11:00 : Talk 1 : Rosdi RASHED :
Christian HOUZEL As A Historian of Mathematics
Click here for link to recording
Click here for Speakers Overheads and related material
—oOo—
11:00 – 11:45 : Talk 2 : Pierre SCHAPIRA : An Application of Houzel’s Theorem of Finitude to Quantification through Deformation
Click here for link to recording
Click here for Speakers Overheads and related material
—oOo—
11:45 – 12:30 : Talk 3 : Erwan PENCHEVRE : The Arithmetic Theory of Algebraic Magnitudes in Kronecker
Click here for link to recording
Click here for Speakers Overheads and related material
—oOo—
LUNCH
—oOo—
14:30-15:15 : Talk 4 : F.W. LAWVERE : Toposes in Geometry and in Analysis
Click here for link to recording
Click here for Notes of Board Presentation and related material
—oOo–
15:30-16:15 : Talk 5 : Francois CHARGOIS : Dualite de Grothendieck
Click here for link to recording
Click here for Speakers Overheads or Notes of Presentation and related material
—oOo—
16:30 – 17:15 : Talk 6 : Alain MICHEL : Borel Measure and Lebesgue Integartion : An Initial Draft of Their History
Click here for link to recording
Click here for Speakers Overheads and related material
—oOo—
Closure of Symposium followed by Reception and Vin D’Honneur
—oOo—
23rd NOVEMBER 2007
Sigma Club Meeting Room T 206 Lakatos Building CPNSS LSE London
Speaker : Joss UFFINK : Motivating Outcome Independence : Locality versus Sufficiency
Click here for Recording of this Talk
Click here for Speakers Overheads or Notes of talk and related material
—oOo—
29th NOVEMBER – 3rd DECEMBER 2007
Trends in The Mathematical Representation of Space : An International Symposium to Honour the 50th Anniversary of the Appearance of Alexandre Grothendieck’s Tohoku Paper
An International Symposium forming part of the 2007 – 2008 Program of The Boston Colloquium for The Philosophy of Science
Boston UNIVERSITY, Boston, Massachusetts, USA
29th NOVEMBER 2007
Arrival and Welcome of Speakers.
Memorandum and Notes of informal discussions between speakers : Pierre CARTIER, F.W. LAWVERE and Colin McLARTY
—oOo—
30th NOVEMBER 2007 : Boston University Department of Philosophy
3:00 PM : Invited Lecture by Pierre CARTIER (CNRS/IHES France)
On The Naturalness of Mathematics : Towards A Relativized Ontology for Mathematics
(Followed by Questions and General Discussion)
Click here for link to recording.
Click here for Speakers Overheads and related material.
—oOo—
See following Abstract of Talk :
The question of the nature of mathematical concepts and ideas has often been hotly debated. Every science has its object or objects – a being or world of beings to be studied, classified and theorised. The objects of mathematics are clearly somewhat special, being in some sense more abstract than those of other disciplines. But mathematicians experience the need to give a reference to their concepts, in order to provide justification for their reasoning about them and to support their constructions and guide their intuitions. Over the centuries the favoured candidates for thus securing reference have changed drastically – from geometrical figures and the tools to design and construct them, then to an algebra based on numbers and symbols upon which various operations are to be defined and performed, later transitioning to ideal objects of various types, such as points at infinity, imaginary numbers, ideal divisors in a number theory whose subject matter has become more and more structural in character. In the late 19th and early 20th Century Cantorian set theory provided a new paradigm for the unification of this realm of referents, providing a representation in principle for all kinds of mathematical objects. But a naively realistic point of view about sets led to inconsistencies. These can be addressed by shifting to a formalistic point of view, but the naturalness of mathematical constructions is thereby lost and the artificiality of these constructions leads to a “Glass Perlen Spiel”
One way out of this impasse makes use of the reflexivity of mathematical thinking. Being a science of abstraction(s), mathematics can reflect on its own modus operandi and review its own activity in mathematical terms. This historical trend of symbolism and formalism has led to the creation of metamathematics. We view metamathematics as a level of constructive activity within mathematics itself, not as a separate science or autonomous justification of mathematics. We propose a view of mathematics as an elaborate and diverse family of projects of construction – involving the fabrication of tools with a conceptual purpose. 20th century developments in formal logic, programming languages, computer science and information theory have been one of the most impressiveoutcomes of this trend. Mathematics can benefit from taking itself as its own object of study. this offers a radically new perspective on and new kinds of proposals for, mathematical ontology.
—oOo—
This Invited Lecture was a separate event, taking place before the Commencement of the Symposium.
—oOo—
The Symposium : 1st – 3rd DECEMBER 2007 : Boston Colloquium For the Philosophy of Science
Photonics Centre, Boston University, Boston, Massachusetts
Day One : 1st DECEMBER 2007
Talk 1 : Pierre CARTIER (CNRS/IHES Paris)
Categories and Sets Living in A Contradictory World.
(Revised Title :
Categories, Sets and Universes : Living on the Edge of Contradiction)
Click here for link to recording
Click here for Speakers Overheads and related material
—oOo—
Talk 2 : Colin McLARTY (CWRU Cleveland)
On Generality and Unity in Grothendieck’s Conception of Geometry
Click here for link to recording
Click here for Speakers Overheads and related material
—oOo—
LUNCH
—oOo—
Talk 3 : F.W. LAWVERE (S.U.N.Y. at Buffalo)
Euler, Maxwell and Grothendieck : Three Phases in the Search for the Correct Mathematical Representation of the Cohesion and Variation involved in our Notion of Space
Click here for link to recording
Click here for Speakers Overheads and related material
—oOo—
Talk 4 : Jean-Pierre MARQUIS (University of Montreal)
From Klein to Kan : The Algebra of Space and the Space of Algebras
Click here for link to recording
Click here for Speakers Overheads and related material
—oOo—
Talk 5 : Michaela IFTIME (Boston University and MCPHS) :
Grothendieck’s Universe.
Click here for link to recording
Click here for Speakers Overheads and related material
—oOo—
Day Two : 2nd DECEMBER 2007
Talk 1 : Lou CRANE (KSU)
What Does Quantum Gravity Tell Us About The Nature of Space/Spacetime ?
Click here for link to recording
Click here for Speakers Overheads and related material
Click here for link to recording
Click here for Speakers Overheads and related material
—oOo—
Talk 2 : Gonzalo REYES (Univ of Montreal)
An Axiomatic Approach to Einstein’s Field Equations in The Framework of Synthetic Differential Geometry
Click here for link to recording
Click here for Speakers Overheads and related material
—oOo—
LUNCH
—oOo—
Talk 3 : Shawn WESTMORELAND (KSU)
The Twin Paradox Without Acceleration
Click here for link to recording
Click here for Speakers Overheads and related material
Click here for link to recording
Click here for Speakers Overheads and related material
—oOo—
Final Session of Symposium : Round Table Discussion of Trends in the Mathematical Representation of Space
on the 50th Anniversdary of Grothendieck’s Tohoku paper
Panel members : Pierre CARTIER, F.W. LAWVERE, Colin McLARTY, Jean-Pierre MARQUIS, John STACHEL, Lou CRANE
Click here for Recording of Panel Discussion
—oOo—
Closure of Symposium
—oOo—
Symposium Dinner
—oOo—
29th November – 3rd December 2007
Notes and Memoranda of Discussions between Symposiasts outside the Formal Sessions of The Symposium. Includes Memorandum of Discussions with F.W. Lawvere, P. Cartier, J-P. Marquis, Colin McLarty and others on such topics as Stone Representation vis-a-vis position of Hilbert Space in Functional Analysis, reasons for bad functoriality of Quantisation; Grothendieck’s implicit proposals for “Bypassing Logic” and his 1973 aide-memoire to Duskin; the Adjoint Functor Theorem and the background to Kan’s discovery of it; Category-theoretic perspectives on Differential Geometry; and many other topics to be further detailed here.
—oOo—
Further Entries for November 2007 to be added.